Ethnic profiling court case encourages travellers to report incidents

Time and again, being singled out from the queue at the airport, whilst other passengers are simply allowed to carry on. Following a call for reports last year, the Amsterdam Region Discrimination Hotline (MDRA) and fellow anti-discrimination organisations regularly received similar reports from travellers with darker skin or a migrant background. These reports underscore the importance of the court case against the State on 15 June 2021.
A coalition of civil society organisations and members of the public, including the anti-discrimination organisation RADAR, is calling on the court to put an end to ethnic profiling during border checks carried out by the Royal Netherlands Marechaussee.

Victims of ethnic profiling can turn to the Amsterdam Region Discrimination Helpline or one of the other anti-discrimination organisations for help and support. For many people who report such incidents, having someone to listen to them after such a traumatic experience is important, but these organisations also offer support in following the complaints procedures. Together with one of the claimants in the court case, the anti-discrimination organisation RADAR went through the complaints procedure with the Royal Netherlands Marechaussee and subsequently referred the case to the National Ombudsman. After the National Ombudsman ruled in the man’s favour, he was once again subjected to ethnic profiling at the same airport. The aim of the legal action is to put a stop to such practices.

Reports in 2020
Reports of ethnic profiling at airports have been dealt with by complaints advisers at the Kennemerland Discrimination Office, ADV Limburg, RADAR and the Amsterdam Region Discrimination Hotline. Here is a selection of the reports received:

  • A man of African descent often travels via Schiphol and says that he is always the only one to be checked by the Marechaussee.
  • A man of North African origin is, every time he departs from Rotterdam-The Hague Airport, taken out of the queue by the Marechaussee and questioned. “At one point, I’d had enough of it and started flying from Belgium or Germany instead.”
  • A woman of Surinamese origin arrives at Schiphol Airport with her white Dutch partner. She is checked twice by the Marechaussee, whilst her partner was not checked.
  • “My wife and I were the only passengers with dark skin. When we arrived at Rotterdam-The Hague Airport, we were the only ones checked by the Marechaussee; all the other passengers were allowed to carry on as normal,” says a man of Surinamese origin.
  • A resident of Eindhoven of Turkish origin regularly flies from Eindhoven Airport to Turkey and is always subject to checks. “Every time, on departure and on my return, the Military Police to show my ID. Recently, I was checked again whilst hundreds of other passengers were simply allowed to walk straight through. At first I thought it was a coincidence, but now I think it’s because I look foreign.”

About the court case
The court case on 15 June centres on the question of whether the Royal Netherlands Marechaussee is permitted to select people for checks, partly on the basis of their appearance, skin colour or presumed origin (ethnicity). The claimants in this case are: Amnesty International, Controle Alt Delete, the Dutch Lawyers’ Committee for Human Rights (NJCM), the RADAR Anti-Discrimination Bureau and two members of the public who have repeatedly been subjected to ethnic profiling by the Royal Netherlands Marechaussee. The proceedings are being coordinated by lawyers from PILP-NJCM. The parties are also being assisted by lawyers from Houthoff.

Report ethnic profiling
Travellers who are stopped by the military police and suspect that this is happening because of their skin colour or ethnic origin can report this to the Amsterdam Region Discrimination Hotline or one of the other anti-discrimination organisations. Reporting helps to tackle discrimination. Go to www.discriminatie.nl or download the ‘Discriminatiemelder’ app from your app store.